ANSS Subject and Bibliographic Access Committee
Question/Answer on cataloging issues – February 2013
Question: How are sexual minorities and alternative genders being treated in subject headings?
By Wade Kotter, Weber State University
The most general subject heading used by the Library of Congress for sexual minorities and alternative genders, including classes of people whose physical sexual characteristics do not match their biological sex and/or their gender identity, is Sexual minorities, which may be subdivided geographically. Narrower headings under Sexual minorities and related headings can be divided for descriptive purposes into four groups:
1. Headings for classes of sexual minority people based on ethnicity, religion, age, gender & other general criteria (each of these headings may be subdivided geographically):
Alaska Native sexual minorities
Asian American sexual minorities
Hispanic American sexual minorities
Indian sexual minorities
Pacific Islander American sexual minorities
Jewish sexual minorities
Unitarian Universalist sexual minorities
Sexual minority youth
Middle-aged sexual minorities
Older sexual minorities
Sexual minority parents
Sexual minority students
Sexual minority college students
Sexual minority consumers
Sexual minority religious leaders
Sexual minorities with disabilities
Sexual minority women
[As is common in LCSH the term “sexual minorities” is used both for “sexual minority men” as well as male and female sexual minorities treated collectively. In other words, “Sexual minority men” is not an established heading in LC subject headings. LCSH does not usually establish a separate heading for men of a category.]
2. Headings for various alternative genders, each of which has several narrower headings; note that Gays is used for homosexuals collectively, Gay men for male homosexuals, and Lesbians for female homosexuals (each of these headings may be subdivided geographically):
Bisexuals
Bisexual college students
Bisexual high school students
Bisexual librarians
Bisexual men
Bisexual parents
Bisexual students
Bisexual women
Bisexual youth
African American bisexuals
Asian American bisexuals
Pacific Islander American Bisexuals
Gays (Covers homosexuals in general; former heading was Homosexuals)
Gay activists
Gay actors
Gay anthropologists
Gay artists
Gay athletes
Gay authors
Gay bodybuilders
Gay broadcasters
Gay businessmen
Gay caregivers
Gay cartoonists
Gay clergy
Gay coaches (Athletics)
Gay college students
Gay college teachers
Gay composers
Gay conductors (Music)
Gay conservatives
Gay counselors
Gay couples
Gay critics
Gay dramatists
Gay executives
Gay fathers
Gay flight attendants
Gay heroes
Gay high school students
Gay human services personnel
Gay immigrants
Gay journalists
Gay kings and rulers
Gay labor union members
Gay lawyers
Gay legislators
Gay librarians
Gay men
Gay men, White
Gay men, Black
Gay military cadets
Gay military personnel
Gay musicians
Gay nurses
Gay parents
Gay photographers
Gay physical education teachers
Gay police officers
Gay political refugees
Gay politicians
Gay private investigators
Gay psychiatrists
Gay psychoanalysts
Gay psychologists
Gay real estate agents
Gay sailors
Gay singers
Gay skinheads
Gay social workers
Gay spies
Gay students
Gay teachers
Gay teenagers
Gay travelers
Gay youth
Buddhist gays
Catholic gays
Christian gays
Closeted gays
Gays with disabilities
Indian gays
Jewish gays
Middle-aged gays
Minority gays
Mormon gays
Muslim gays
Older gays
Protestant gays
African American gays
Asian American gays
Hispanic American gays
Italian American gays
Mexican American gays
Pacific Islander American gays
South Asian American gays
Lesbians
Lesbian activists
Lesbian actresses
Lesbian anthropologists
Lesbian artists
Lesbian athletes
Lesbian authors
Lesbian businesswomen
Lesbian cartoonists
Lesbian clergy
Lesbian college students
Lesbian college teachers
Lesbian composers
Lesbian couples
Lesbian dramatists
Lesbian girl scouts
Lesbian high school students
Lesbian librarians
Lesbian mothers
Lesbian motorcyclists
Lesbian musicians
Lesbian nuns
Lesbian nurses
Lesbian photographers
Lesbian physical education teachers
Lesbian police officers
Lesbian private investigators
Lesbian psychotherapists
Lesbian rabbis
Lesbian students
Lesbian teachers
Lesbian teenagers
Lesbian youth
Abused lesbians
Abusive lesbian partners
Christian lesbians
Indian lesbians
Jewish lesbians
Middle-aged lesbians
Minority lesbians
Older lesbians
Puerto Rican lesbians
Rural lesbians
Working class lesbians
African American lesbians
Asian American lesbians
Cuban American lesbians
Hispanic American lesbians
Italian American lesbians
Mexican American lesbians
Pacific Islander American lesbians
Transgender people
Transgender athletes
Transgender children
Transgender college students
Transgender librarians
Transgender military personnel
Transgender musicians
Transgender parents
Transgender prisoners
Transgender veterans
Transgender youth
Christian transgender people
Female impersonators
Jewish transgender people
Male impersonators
Transvestites
3. Headings for classes of people whose physical sexual characteristics do not match with their gender identity (and sometimes their biological sex as well) and who usually undergo sex change surgery (each of the following headings may be subdivided geographically):
Transsexuals
Transsexual college students
Transsexual librarians
Transsexual parents
Transsexual students
Transsexual youth
Christian transsexuals
Female-to-male transsexuals
Jewish transsexuals
Male-to-female transsexuals
Older transsexuals
African American transsexuals
4. Headings for classes of people whose physical sexual characteristics do not match their biological sex (each of the following headings may be subdivided geographically):
Intersex people
Intersex athletes
Intersex children
Intersex military personnel
Thank you for your suggestions, David. My apology for not responding sooner. The list given in this Q&A was meant to include only current, officially established LC subject headings. The three suggestions you give are not established headings. In order to propose these as new subject headings you would need to work with a SACO certified cataloger to submit a new subject heading proposal to the Library of Congress. I’m very doubtful that these suggestions would be accepted because LC clearly distinguishes (rightly or wrongly) between Transgender people as a class of people and Gays, Gay men and Lesbians as classes of people. Regardless, if you would like to pursue the process of proposing these as new subject headings, please let us know. Wade